Thursday, July 12, 2007

Another Question

I read one of my book choices and wrote my version of a review (have patience with me, I've not had much experience in reviewing), and realized that I'm not entirely sure what to do with it. So here's a question about how things should work once everyone begins reading. Do we all post here and reference reviews on our own blogs, like I see Rhinoa has done, or should the first one to read a particular book post his/her review on this site, using the title of the book as the title of the post, and all subsequent readers add their reviews/comments to the initial post for the book, or yet another option, does our kind host create an empty post (just a title) for each book, and we use the comments to discuss and link to our reviews?

Why, oh why, does this person keep asking questions??? Well, I took one of those online quizzes and found out that I can't accomplish anything without explicit, intricately detailed, step-by-step instructions. ;)


Lisa said...

There aren't actually any rules. How Rhinoa has done it is fine, although it creates some confusion about where the comments/discussion should go -- on her blog or on her post here..

My preference would be to have people cross-post their reviews both on their own blog and also here...then discussion could happen in the comments section on this blog for the people who are participating in this challenge.

There isn't a WRONG way, though, so do what seems like the best for you!

JMC said...

OK. Thanks!

Rhinoa said...

I updated my post to include the book review here as well.